First off, this is only a review of the first of two discs. The second disc is all acousticy-chill stuff and will be examined in future update. The first disc, however, is 10 songs of brute rock a lá typical Foo Fighters—which is rarely ever a bad thing. Without further ado:
1. “
In Your Honor” – The title track. It starts off how rock a rock album should: incoherent distortion that continuously grows towards one massive “AHHHHHHHHH” at the end. The lyrics are good, but nothing spectacular. Dave screams about how he, ahem, screams about his willingness to sacrifice his life for your honor “for you to feel alive.” Good stuff overall, and jumps right into song two…
(Overall: 9/10)2. “
No Way Back” – The riff that starts this song is a combination of “Win or Lose” (A FF’ single from the “Out Cold” soundtrack—great song) and “A Crow Left of the Murder” (The song, not the entire album). The fact that this riff is a little reminiscent of both of these tunes is by no means a bad thing; on the contrary, the familiarity gets you fist-pumping immediately. The lyrics to the chorus have a pretty cool theme about them: meeting someone for the first time, feeling that chemistry immediately, and just going crazy having a good time while not looking back (get all that?).
(Overall: 9/10)3. “
Best of You” – Seriously, if you haven’t heard this song yet, then it’s kind of odd that you’d even care about a FF CD review in the first place. Nevertheless, this song rocks, and will no doubt be a live staple for the remainder of the Foo’s days. The synchronization of the guitars and drums make the perfect backdrop for the vocals—which are clearly out front and the highlight of the song. Lyrically, the rhyme scheme is amazing, and while you might expect that to hinder the actual flow of words, it actually moves nicely.
(Overall: 10/10)4. “
DOA” – This song would be 100% kickass if it weren’t for the overly-pop chorus. It doesn’t work with the theme of the lyrics and the music for the verses (which are awesome). In my opinion, this song is clearly about a breakup/divorce. We can only hope Dave is speaking metaphorically when he says “It’s a shame we have to die, my dear/No one’s getting out of here alive/this time.”
(Overall 7.5/10)5. “
Hell” – To my taste, this song just doesn’t have enough to ever really get going. This may be due to the fact that the song is a few seconds under two minutes. Even still, the song just doesn’t seem like it’s rocking enough to be singing “Sing farewell/see you in hell.” The vocals are really good, though. Kinda makes you wonder if Dave would’ve been in an a’capella group had he finished high school…
(Overall: 7/10) 6. “
The Last Song” – I’m not sure what to make of this one. It’s good, but I don’t find myself as excited as I do earlier in the album. A catchy chorus that’s really only two lines long, Dave sings about how he’s tired [of you] and damn it, this is the last song he’s going to dedicate to you. Reminds me of that thing where people tell you over and over again how they’re “not gonna talk to you anymore.”
(Overall: 7/10)7. “
Free Me” – Now we’re rocking again! This song has a killer riff that continues thru most of the song, and the lyrics are all about Dave needing to be freed from his mind and thoughts because they’re reminding him of all the bad times. The outro is also definitely a keeper: “Oh! O-oo! Oh!” I… I guess you have to hear it.
(Overall: 9/10)8. “
Resolve” – re•solve (r -z lv ) – 1.To make a firm decision about. See also slower FF songs: “Big Me,” “Walking After You,” “Halo,” or “Next Year” (there’s one on every album). The noticeably slower song doesn’t quite do it for me. It definitely has it’s moments, but as a whole, it sounds to me like the type of song the rest of the band would play live with absolutely zero emotion on their faces.
(Overall 7/10)9. “
The Deepest Blues Are Black” – Amen, brotha Dave. Dave holds back nothing on this one calling out “Shame on you/Seducing everyone/You faded jewel/You diamond in the rough/You don’t have to tell me/I know where you’ve been.” Me-ow! I swear if Dave Grohl were a woman, he’d have just called some other ho a bitch started ripping out her hair. Alas, he’s not a she, he’s a he, and he writes really groovin’ songs like this. The verse builds you towards a gut-wrenching chorus.
(Overall (9/10)10. “
End Over End” – This is how you end an album. From the first strums, this song gets your head bobbing, and once the lyrics come in, they don’t disappoint. Before the second pre-chorus/chorus section hits, you’re already singing along, which is either a sign of a shitty song (anyone remember that god-awful “Follow Me” song Uncle Kracker did?) or a really kickass one that is one giant cathartic release because it hits home so instantly. I’ll let you guess which category this one falls under. Needless to say, I have a hard time not speeding on the highway when I listen to this one
(Overall: 10/10)All in all, this CD most definitely met the expectations that were looming for the much-talked about double-feature. Dave said the idea of doing one rock and one acoustic disc was intriguing because it would allow him to go as hard as he wanted, and as soft as he wanted. While this may not be the Foo’s hardest rocking tunes (see practically every title on the self-titled album), it certainly shows the always improving songwriting skills of the Lord and Savior of Rock—Dave Grohl.
Must Listen To: “In Your Honor,” “No Way Back,” “Best of You,” “The Deepest Blues Are Black,” and “End Over End.”
Could’ve Done Without: “Hell” and “Resolve”
Overall: 9/10